ALL AGES READS: THE BABY-SITTERS CLUB

[MattBrady]

by Tracy, Sarah and Shelby Edmunds

The Baby-sitters Club series of novels for young girls, written (mostly) by Ann M. Martin, has been around since 1986. The original series of 131 titles spawned several spin-off book series, which run to over 200 titles, as well as board games and dolls, a TV show, and a movie. For years it was a children’s publishing juggernaut, so it’s no surprise that the folks at Scholastic Graphix chose The Baby-sitters Club as one of their first graphic novel adaptations. And who better to do the adaptation than a former babysitter and lifelong fan of the series? Raina Telgemeier, 2005 Eisner Award nominee for Talent Deserving of Wider Recognition, brings the gang from Stoneybrook to life better than I think anyone else could have.

The main characters are a group of 7th grade girls who form a baby-sitting club and become fast friends. Along the way we meet their parents, the families they sit for, and other kids at the girls’ school…and yes, some boys as well. The girls share with each other, keep secrets, support each other, disagree, and work together to turn failures into successes. This is really a refreshing change from many of the graphic novels we’ve been reading because there are no superheroes or villains, no violence, and nothing too adult, just true-to-life girls doing everyday girl things.

Raina’s spare, cartoony style belies the depth of her work – the whole thing just feels so real. She very effectively uses background, or the lack thereof, to focus the reader’s attention. When she wants us to focus on the characters’ expressions or conversation, the backgrounds are almost completely empty, and when she’s establishing place and action, her backgrounds are fully realized. These are not action stories, but there’s never a dull moment thanks to the constant movement and expression of the characters. The Baby-sitters Club graphic novels are thoroughly entertaining and I couldn’t get the girls to put them down. Not only are these great books for young girls, they are also wonderful for grown-up girls. Will boys like The Baby-sitters Club? Of course, but only if no one catches them reading their sister’s copy!

Shelby says: The Baby-sitters Club is about four girls who baby-sit little kids by setting up a club. Mary Anne only has a dad because her mom died when she was little and she’s sort of shy and likes to read, like me. Kristy has about twenty other siblings and she’s not shy at all – she’s the leader of the club. Claudia likes to do art, like me, and she’s sort of punk. Stacey is new in town and she has a secret. They meet at Claudia’s house and they talk about what they can change and what’s been doing well. They also get phone calls from people who need babysitters. Then they all go out and do babysitting jobs and they write about it in a journal.

I like the part when they go on the babysitting jobs because some of the kids are weird and cause trouble and some of them are nice and sweet. Lots of funny things happen when they go babysitting. I just can’t stop reading this. I say, “I’m going to put it down now,” but I always end up reading about 35 pages more. This is because of the art. I like sometimes how Raina uses highlights and shadows only on some things, like chairs, hats, and hair. I like the doggies because they are cute and they have detail in their fur. The little kids that Kristy, Claudia, Mary Anne, and Stacey baby-sit are adorable!

Sarah says: I liked Baby-sitters Club 1 and 2 because all of the characters had different personalities. My favorite characters would have to be Jamie, a little boy that they baby-sit, because he is all cute and stuff and seems like a nice person, and Stacy because she wears good clothes and she’s nice, too. I liked the drawings – it doesn’t feel realistic and it doesn’t feel make believe either. I like reading about kids who are older because I wanna know what it’s going to be like when I get older. It’s basically about regular kids doing regular stuff, but it’s not boring because there’s competition and they talk about cool stuff a lot and it’s funny. I think Baby-sitters Club is for people who like Archie, because it’s kind of like that.

The Baby-sitters Club; Kristy’s Great Idea (you can check out a preview here) and The Baby-sitters Club; The Truth About Stacey are available now, with more titles on the way. These books belong in every children’s library and classroom! And if you haven’t seen Raina’s webcomic, Smile, click right now! I would never have guessed that I’d truly enjoy a comic about dental work.

Come back next week for our interview with David Saylor, Creative Director for Scholastic Graphix.

Email the authors: allagescomics@hotmail.com

[PhilipAMoore]

I bought these for a friend and read them before giving them they both injoy able reads I'd like to see more adaptation I read the first book of the reguler series out of curiosity the adaptation are acurate

good day

[Mick]

I remember my sisters being obsessed with the books and tv show.




That art is great, though.

[bishop-m]

These look like a great read...I might have to check them out...

[Impulse725]

I'm totally in favor of anything appearing in a comic format that might further the medium. My sister would have loved these when she was little.

[RedBaron]

I met Raina briefly at the Paradise Toronto Comic Con. She was part of a Women and Comics panel I attended, and I bought one of her mini comics from her booth later on. Her work is very cut but also very expressive. Fans of the Babysitting Club should check out these books.

[Renonevada2000]

Would these be good for a 9-10 year old? I've been looking for some comics for my future step-daughter.

[Comic Mom]

Originally Posted by Renonevada2000

Would these be good for a 9-10 year old? I've been looking for some comics for my future step-daughter.

Absolutely. Shelby is ten and she really enjoyed them both.

[librarykat]

Originally Posted by Comic Mom

Absolutely. Shelby is ten and she really enjoyed them both.

The Baby-Sitters Club books appealed to mostly girls ages 8 to 11 in the library where I worked when the series started 20 years ago. The series remained hugely popular, I had to replace worn out copies fairly often. The comics adaptation by Telgemeier is absolutely delightful, libraries are buying them and introducing the BSC to a new generation of readers. And since they're in comics form, libraries are introducing even more young girls to the format. All to the good. This series and Amelia Rules! by Jimmy Gownley (self-published from Renaissance Press) are two standout comics titles for young girls ages 8 to 11 or 12.

BTW, I love this column, since in my work as a graphic novel consultant for libraries, I seek out lots of all-ages comics.

[KyleCowstar]

God bless Scholastic for doing more for the growth of the cmoics industry than Marvel or DC.