Spider-Man Action Figures

WWE Action Figures

home


Go Back   NEWSARAMA > FEATURES

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 03-31-2008, 10:22 AM   #1
MattBrady
 
BRIAN BENDIS: THE BROAD VIEW OF SECRET INVASION

by Matt Brady

There’s this little story coming up from Marvel this week called Secret Invasion.

Over four years in the making, the story will be told in a central, eight issue miniseries by Brian Bendis and Leinil Francis Yu, and literally dozens of tie-in issues and spin-off miniseries. At the center of the story – a secret invasion of the earth by the shapeshifting alien Skrulls. On one level, it’s a good, old-fashioned alien enemy that the superheroes of the Marvel Universe can punch; while on another, there are more than enough parallels to keep fans and non-fans keeping the messageboards hot all summer (invading force with superior firepower telling the natives that they have a better way for them to live, anyone?).

In the first of three conversations with Bendis coming this week, we sat down with the writer to talk about the broader picture of Secret Invasion, its parallels, how it came to be, the reaction it will most likely garner, and more.

Newsarama: Brian, let’s start on a broad view since we’re close to the first issue, and more can be said. Something that struck me from the Entertainment Weekly interview was that the root of this isn’t the militaristic, “Mwha-ha-ha!” evil alien invasion, but it’s prophecy based and rooted in the Skrull religion and psyche as much as anything else.

Brian Bendis: Yeah. There’s been a full build of than in the Skrull mythology over the past couple of decades. We’ve all seen alien invasions, in every form of media known to man. When they feel most real, when the argument is, in fact, arguable - that’s when it gets more interesting. I always hearken back to Magneto – you can even buy the “Magneto was right!” t-shits – people like the villains who can look you in the eye, completely express themselves, and you end up saying, “…well, you’ve got a point, but I’ve got a problem with what you’re doing.” Or they could maybe even charm you into taking their side. What we’ve got here is something that will be along those lines. The Skrulls are going to offer something better than what we have, maybe. So right there, it’s a case of, “Okay – point taken, we have some problems here on earth, and you don’t have those problems, so maybe we should be a part of the Skrull Empire.”

NRAMA: But to them, earth is in/is part of the Skrull Empire, correct?

BB: Right. It’s what they believe to be true – the earth is already part of the Empire. What’s important in all of this is that, much like on earth, we all don’t believe in the same thing, we all don’t like the same comics, and we all don’t believe in the same god. It’s the same thing with the Skrulls – there are certain sects that believe in certain things and other ones that don’t, or some people believe things more religiously than others. There are Skrulls that hate Reed Richards with a passion, and there are people who don’t care about him at all and just want to get on with their lives. It’s just like what we have on earth.

Now, imagine that with an eighteen-world empire. There are that many more feelings and belief systems at work. So, who’s coming here now may be people with a completely different belief system than those who were here before. So they were here before with an agenda, which was right, as far as they were concerned, but the belief system maybe wasn’t enough to support it.

NRAMA: To try to clarify with an equally nerdy analogy, you’ve got the smooth-headed Klingons and the wrinkly-headed Klingons (which carries its own weighty explanation), as well as Klingons who don’t always see things the same as their leaders…

BB: That’s a pretty good example. In Secret Invasion, we’re going to meet those people. Particularly in New Avengers, we’re going to pull the curtain back and see things from their point of view. It’s a huge disservice to any comic book story to spend all the time developing the heroes and giving them such three dimensional personalities as many writers have in mainstream comics, and not do the same to who, or whatever the antagonists of the story are.

If you look at some of the most popular villains, Lex Luthor, Dr. Doom, Magneto – those are the ones that we totally know where they’re coming from, and that makes them more interesting. Not that you’re rooting for them, but you understand them. That makes the fight so much better. That’s what will be happening here. They will not just be bald, wrinkled chin, greedy, laser gun totin’, spaceship flyin’ aliens coming to get us. They’re not the boogeymen. There’s something else afoot here.

NRAMA: So it’s a manifest destiny thing, an empire-building exercise…

BB: Right – and at Marvel, that’s when it really clicks - when we find that little nugget, that thing where it’s a real-world connection, something that we all can relate to. We live in a country that was literally built upon manifest destiny and we’re watching the world be invaded and separated and jihaded. We know what this feels like, and we know what it means.

NRAMA: So, not to put too fine a point on it, you’ve got an invading force with superior firepower, coming to what they see as a backwater planet, telling the inhabitants that they have a better way and they will make them follow their way, and this invading force is encountering resistance…that’s the nugget of the real amidst the larger story, costumes, and rocketships?

BB: Exactly. And that’s the kind of thing that when you’re pitching a story to Joe [Quesada]…if you start with “Okay, aliens invade the earth…” he glasses over, and starts to stare at the wall; but when you add in what you just said there, and the connections come together for him, he wakes up and gets really interested. I like to see the Marvel heroes involved in these kinds of stories that ask many of the same questions we’re faced with. There’s an argument to be had, and stories to be told.

NRAMA: But at the same time, you do have readers who are bemoaning the face that their escapist reading has less and less “escape” in it. You mentioned 9/11 in your Entertainment Weekly interview, and that pushed a lot of buttons, both of recognition and of complaint. How much “real” is too real?

BB: It’s a valid question, but my line and [Civil War writer] Mark’s [Millar] line is very similar: anything that isn’t preaching. Anything that isn’t Captain America looking at the camera telling you what’s wrong with you. It’s story and characters first, and subtext should be subtext. I can’t stand being preached to, and it’s not in me to do it. All the stuff that we’re talking about are the fascinating questions that people hopefully will enjoy throughout. We have a community of fans online, discussing things all day. Now we, the publishers ask a question – “Who Do You Trust?” “Whose Side are You On?” They’re questions that can carry you through the summer. People are still arguing about the issues of Civil War, and that’s been over for over a year now. We put out the “Who Do You Trust?” question, and it’s the greatest thing in my life to see 17 Skrull threads – not one, but 17. And they’re all having a blast and talking up. They’re asking the question to – they’re asking it on the nerdiest level, they’re asking it on the sociological level. It’s good.

I think it was Oliver Stone who said that your job as a storyteller is to ask the question, not to answer it. No preaching. There will be heroes hitting villains – but for a reason. You need a reason.

NRAMA: Going back to the origins of the story – and obviously, some more can be said now, but you’ve maintained that the Skrull invasion storyline was in your mind back in the days of Avengers Disassembled and New Avengers #1 days. Was it a flash, something where you just had the sudden thought of, “They’re all Skrulls!” or was it a slower thing that grew up inside you as an idea?

BB: Anybody who writes or draws comics has a “wouldn’t it be cool?” list, and the great thing is when you get this job, you get to do that, or you get to pitch things from your list. I did have this list of thing that I would love to do, and I saw the Skrulls as something that you could scrape the cheese off of, and really do something cool with. When took over Avengers, I thought, “This is the place to do it.”

Also, about the same time that I took Avengers, I signed a rather long contract with Marvel, which allowed me to do longer-form storytelling, which a lot of my peers just don’t have. Geoff Johns can, and he’s doing it on Green Lantern for one, but largely, there’s a lot of hit-and-run going on in comics nowadays, which is just the nature of freelancing. But, I’m just in a position where I can tell longer-form stories, and it kind of dawned on me that there’s almost an obligation to try something like that as well. If I’m one of the two guys who can do it, then I should do it.

And I do appreciate and love that kind of stuff, so I threw it out there right away for New Avengers, and it was always supposed to be an Avengers reveal and an Avengers story. But as Civil War hit and World War Hulk hit, yes, a market opening for these big stories in the summer, but the Avengers franchise also altered. Though the books are doing really well now, it wasn’t written in stone that it was going to happen at the time. Again, it was going to be an Avengers reveal, a big Avengers summer storyline, but a lot of organic stuff happened to it. Civil War got pitched, and we all agreed that it just accentuated what I was going to do, which was fantastic – it made me feel like I was going in the right direction. Here was something that totally helped the Skrulls.

“You guys want to go ahead and kill each other? Oh please, by all means.”

“You guys are going to create a situation where the Hulk beats the crap out of you? Please. We won’t stand in the way.”

It really felt like things were organically building towards a great place for the storyline to tell. It really made me feel like I was telling the right story – everything was fitting in.

So that happened, and then, organically, two Avengers books happened, and now it can be revealed that one of the reasons that I took on the second series as well as that, knowing that my Skrull story was happening, I needed to do both. In the time it would have taken for me to hold someone’s hand or to be preventing someone else from telling the stories that they really wanted to tell because all of this Skrull stuff was happening, would’ve been a nightmare for another writer to have to deal with. So, by doing both, I was able to build the story the way I wanted, and then, by doing both books, I’ve got characters on both teams that are really touching literally every corner of the Marvel Universe: mutants and gods, street level characters, Iron Man as the top cop of the world. Now the Avengers really involved every single aspect of the Marvel Universe.

Joe and Dan then came in and said that since the franchise was built to the point where it was at the center of the Marvel Universe, the storyline had become a “Marvel Universe” story, not just an Avengers story. It was everything.

NRAMA: And that was something of a surprise to you?

BB: Something, yeah. I had already had my event [House of M], and I thought we all only got one. But as they said, if the story and the Skrull plan was as big as I wanted it to be, I had created this Universe-wide event, and it needed to be treated that way, not limited to the Avengers. That’s how Secret Invasion was born.

NRAMA: As you said, you’ve been a part of many events, pretty much going back to the latest wave of them. How does Secret Invasion compare when it comes to the others when it comes to moving it through editorial? Both you and Joe have talked over the years about the arguments and the out-and-out fights that have happened at the Marvel Editorial Retreats over the years – did Secret Invasion get a warm reception when it was brought in to the room of editors and writers?

BB: The biggest difference was that Civil War was born in a room with a bunch of writers, and Mark raised his hand to write it. Secret Invasion was born in my basement and was brought to the room, just like Greg [Pak] was doing World War Hulk and brought it too the room. It was a very similar situation. Other people have brought things to the room, and they don’t survive the room, which kinda means that they wouldn’t survive the internet.

NRAMA: [laughs] Really?

BB: It’s true. The feeling is, if you get out of that room alive, your story is going to go. It ain’t a polite room. It’s kinda awful. It’s fun, but if you get your heart set on something, and someone in the back of the room says, “You know…” and it completely derails your thing, and everyone falls in love with what the other guy just said…it’s not the best day you ever had, that’s for sure.

So I came to the room with the Skrulls as an Avengers event, and was quickly talked out of it in exchange for this, and then everyone started touching it. What’s great about it is that people start throwing out great ideas that you get to keep, and you look like a genius; but at the same time, you have to fight off ideas that you don’t want to do that are terrible. But on the other hand, you’ve got someone like Joe, who’s not really a fan of this type of story, more or less, but if you convince him, you’ve convinced a whole section of people who aren’t necessarily a fan of that type of story that there’s something there, which feels really good.

NRAMA: You still have to convince Joe of the merits of something these days?

BB: [laughs] I know there are a lot of people who think that Joe and I are pals, and I get to do whatever I want, and that is absolutely not the case. That’s why I work there. I don’t need working with “pals” in my life. I need someone who’s going to tell me that I suck when I suck - before it gets printed. So that’s good.

And then me [Jeph] Loeb and I will go at it, and he’s the idea guy and throwing out these big possible ideas at you, and his arguments are fantastic. So the Skrulls survived three whole retreats, so it felt really good. But up to and including that third one, I figured that the next retreat would be the one where the idea gets spiked. But it never happened. Things were added, certain characters were voted on being a Skrull or not…

NRAMA: You didn’t have that set in stone?

BB: Some of the characters were locked down – most of the big ones were locked down from the early days of New Avengers, but as we got closer to the event, everyone wanted to reveal a Skrull or something else, so we had to vote. Sometimes when we voted and we’d all agree that such-and-such character was a Skrull, I’d get home and think, “You know, it doesn’t work,” and have to call in and see about getting things changed back.

NRAMA: So, in your estimation, have you ever gone mad with all of this power?

BB: No – the highlight of it is that Loeb and I will scream at each other to a point where Alan Fine, the President of Marvel Publishing, who’s not at every meeting, said, “I had no idea they were this passionate.” And then I felt embarrassed. I mean, Alan’s like the boss of the boss, and here was I was, screaming myself hoarse at Jeph Loeb in front of him about who’s a Skrull. It was the dumbest conversation two educated men have ever had about other people.

NRAMA: So what was the argument about?

BB: Oh, I can’t say it now, because it ruins a plot point, but it was pretty hilarious.

NRAMA: Moving back to the story itself – what you’ve said about the difference in the Skrull philosophy and the differences in prophecy that they’re following…why now? What got this particular invasion started that, apparently, has been going on for a few years?

BB: Quite a few things came into play. Some of them have been very public, but we’re going to illustrate that very dramatically in the issues that Jimmy Cheung is drawing in New Avengers. We’re going to rewind the clock the to the end of The Illuminati miniseries, and we’re going to see what happened on the very next page, and form there, follow the Skrull Empire all the way through.

Anyone who is reading this that’s a fan of recent Marvel comics knows that the Annihilation Wave was a disaster for the Skrull Empire, Galactus ate the throne world. There’ve been some dramatic, horrible events that have happened to the Skrull empire on top of them losing the Kree-Skrull War and other things that are very public. So we’ll be rewinding them and putting those events in order and showing how they match up with some sects’ prophecies, and may have shifted the tone of how the Skrull Empire handles things.

NRAMA: Speaking of the tie-in issues that show other parts of the story…you’ve mentioned about the Avengers tie-ins before, and what you’re planning there with putting all your cards on the table, but Secret Invasion is an event with a hefty number of tie-ins. How much of a hand did you have in those?

BB: Some of them, I had a pretty big role in. You want to involve as many people as possible to have fun with the big storyline that you’re telling, but you also want to learn the lesson from both companies’ past about what kind and what quality fo crossover you want – at least in theory. The final product will be the final product, and you’ve got to let people tell their stories.

But when I was creating the first issue, I had a few ideas that I put out there – ideas for the Fantastic Four and others. Whether they would choose to go that route or not, I just wanted to put it out there as an opening for a tie in that would be really cool. And my judgment on the tie-in being really cool is if whether or not people could understand the story and find it cool if they weren’t reading the main story. It’s like the Star Trek movies the best ones are the ones where you never had to have seen Star Trek before to enjoy them. If Star Trek IV was the first time you met Captain Kirk, you’d be able to understand the story and have a good time. That’s the same type of thing I was looking for with the tie-ins.

The other thing was not to use them to tell the same joke over and over again, which is have every issue of every thing that happens this summer is a Skrull reveal. We mandated that will not be happening. Everyone had to have a unique pitch and a unique take. A perfect example and an excellent one that I had nothing to do with, other than I put out some of the religious philosophy of the Skrulls came when Fred Van Lente came up with a pitch for the gods of the Marvel Universe which he wanted t use in Incredible Hercules which was better than what we were going to go with.

So it’s a mixture of just throwing out premises – like Roberto writing the Fantastic Four tie-in after he got the one sentence of, “Here’s what could happen with the Fantastic Four…” and he took it and ran and had a blast. That’s great – I would have never told him what story to tell, and Mark was like that with Civil War - you have to let people tell their stories. Treat people the way you would want to be treated.

I know tie-ins are a sticky thing with fans, and sometimes the readers feel abused, but it’s really not how it’s generated on our side. We’re looking at what the best story to tell is, and what’s the most creative way we can handle the story. There were a few guys who wanted to come in and tell a “Skrull story” just because they wanted a bump in their book, but it was the purists, who had something unique to offer to the story – they were the ones that stuck. The final call will be the readers’ call, but whatever you chose to read will only accentuate the experience for you. If you want the single disc DVD, you’ll get the full story. If you want the double disc edition, fine. If you want the Blade Runner five discs with the toy in the briefcase, we’ve got that too.

NRAMA: And of course, any talk of tie-ins comes with the normal admonition that you really don’t need to buy them to enjoy the story…

BB: No you rally don’t, and I think our track record on this is pretty solid. It’s our goal to make you want to buy them, not to make you have to buy them. That’s the mandate all the way down. I want you to read Secret Invasion #1 and get so excited that you buy something that you may not have read before, and try something out.

The only little difference is that most people buying Secret Invasion have been buying Avengers, so those fans are going to get a big reward from what they read in the Avengers tie-ins. So if you’ve been following, you’re going to get a big payoff. You’re not going to be penalized for not buying them, but you’re going to reap some big rewards when we pull the curtain back and show you everything.

NRAMA: One last thing – and this always comes up with you and your bigger stories. You’re on the internet a lot, probably more than you should be…

BB: Probably...[laughs]

NRAMA: You’ve seen the buzz for this, as you mentioned earlier. There have been threads going for a while. There’s so much built up for this, both coming directly from Marvel’s marketing department in various ways, as well as being started up by the fans themselves. At what point does the sheer volume of discussion get to you?

BB: It’s impossible to say that Secret Invasion wasn’t created without that in mind. It doesn’t get to me, really. It doesn’t get to me when I’m criticized or people say nice things about me all day long. I’ve got a pretty good rhino-skin about that, and I can tell a good criticism when I see it. The only thing that really annoys me on the internet is when people take my words out of context or lie about me, like anybody else – being defamed for something you didn’t do or say it what gets to me.

But as far as the guessing game of who is or isn’t and that stuff – there’s nothing about that that isn’t fun to me. And I know that there are a number of people all over online that have decided what they would like out of this. They have written it in their head – particularly, they have decided upon which character they would like to be a Skrull or not to be a Skrull.

Let’s say someone has already decreed in their head that Rocket Raccoon is a Skrull. Let’s say that Rocket Raccoon turns out not to be a Skrull. That equals in their head that I suck, and that will be that for the rest of their lives. I know that, and there’s nothing I can do about that. I can just get a little Zen about it. But even those people who are screaming for my head – they really are having a good time. They’re getting a lot of fun for the few bucks or whatever they’ve put into this so far. I learned a couple of years ago that it’s a game. If you don’t enjoy the game, or can’t handle the game, just don’t be a part of it, you know? But I can handle it pretty well. I enjoy the back and forth. I enjoy the conspiracy theories and all the back and forth.

But my entire summer will be variations on the Rocket Raccoon example, my entire summer.

And I do feel bad – there are people out there who are really big, big fans of certain characters that, since I’ve been writing them, have been just really nice to me, and I know they’re about lose their shit on me. And I feel bad. I’ve felt bad all year. There are some guys whoa re fans of characters that, all year long, have been on my board and just couldn’t be nicer and defend me at every turn, but it was already locked in…

NRAMA: Dead fan walking…

BB: [laughs] But the worst thing is if you put out work and no one gives a shit. That is bad. I’ve had that happen too. This is much better than that. This is what we call a high class problem on any level. There’s nothing wrong with it.

I’m at a point though, where I get more upset when I see people bag on other creators instead of me. I mean, I get more worked up when someone trashes the Coen Brothers than I do when someone trashes me. I know that’s mentally ill. I know that. But that’s okay. I’m sure someone can diagnose that for me, but that’s okay – just leave it. I’m fine [laughs].

Secret Invasion #1 is due in comic book shops on Wednesday.
 
Old 03-31-2008, 02:41 PM   #2
Marius665
 
Are we going to get an chance to do a Q&A with Mr. Bendis?
 
Old 03-31-2008, 02:44 PM   #3
Knowbrainer
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marius665
Are we going to get an chance to do a Q&A with Mr. Bendis?

Probably not.
 
Old 03-31-2008, 02:46 PM   #4
KirkWarren
 
Man, those "Who do you trust?" promo ads are ugly. It's like some photo manipulation attempt gone bad.


Aside from the ending to the Illuminati series, everything I've seen on the Skrulls points towards this being one big One More Day / Brand New Day and while I usually give everything a fair shake, I'm about as excite for this "event" as a root canal. It doesn't help when, after every interview / sound byte from Bendis hits the air, 3 issues later in New Avengers or Mighty Avengers we get to literally read every word Bendis said int he interview coming from the Marvel characters' mouths, as if to validate the hype Bendis is giving this.

I'll still pick this up, but they've got a lot of work ahead of them if they expect me to stick with it or pick up the 50 tie-in issues.
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:02 PM   #5
artiepants
 
i, for one, cannot wait for Thursday.
(my wife works 2 blocks from my LCS and is kind enough to pick up my pulllist for me, but i won't ask her to do it on a wednesday )
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:02 PM   #6
I-Ching
 
I'm interested in this mini-series only because I think it genuinely will effect the Marvel Universe the way that Civil War did.

What happened to the days when the "this will rock the foundations of the _____ universe and change everything!!"...and then nothing really changes...Oh wait, that was DC's Crisis of Crises'es's...and was OYL even anything significant?

MU post-Civil War is actually truly different and it's reflected in all it's titles...I was definitely surprised by this...pleasantly surprised....so now I'm intrigued to see where Bendis will take this now.
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:05 PM   #7
Taxman
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Knowbrainer
Probably not.
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:07 PM   #8
artiepants
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by KirkWarren
Man, those "Who do you trust?" promo ads are ugly. It's like some photo manipulation attempt gone bad.
yeah, they are truly terrible.

Quote:
Originally Posted by KirkWarren
while I usually give everything a fair shake, I'm about as excite for this "event" as a root canal.

I'll still pick this up, but they've got a lot of work ahead of them if they expect me to stick with it or pick up the 50 tie-in issues.
i can't imagine why you'd get it in the first place if you're not excited or into it.

My rule on tie-ins after going a little nuts on CW (although i mostly enjoyed the tie-ins more then the main book, only thing i remember wishing i had skipped were the dreadful Fantastic Four issues.) is i only get what's already on my pull (which SI is pretty much touching on like 3/4s of my list) or something that has a creative team/premise/characters that would get me to try that book anyways. (i.e. Captain Britain and SI: Fantastic Four)
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:09 PM   #9
Hypestyle
 
if my favorite characters are revealed to be skrulls or die during this crossover, I will be depressed beyond consolation..
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:10 PM   #10
Marius665
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by artiepants
yeah, they are truly terrible.


i can't imagine why you'd get it in the first place if you're not excited or into it.

My rule on tie-ins after going a little nuts on CW (although i mostly enjoyed the tie-ins more then the main book, only thing i remember wishing i had skipped were the dreadful Fantastic Four issues.) is i only get what's already on my pull (which SI is pretty much touching on like 3/4s of my list) or something that has a creative team/premise/characters that would get me to try that book anyways. (i.e. Captain Britain and SI: Fantastic Four)

when Civil War happened I got them all except for Front Line

I wont be doing that this time around, Mighty, New Avengers, are the actual tie-in's that I'm grabing

along with the Spidey, F4 and the Young Avengers/Runaways mini's

I dont really care for the rest, like the Captain Britain and the Ms. Marvel or even the X-Factor issues
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:11 PM   #11
Question86
 
Bendis quoting Oliver Stone makes me laugh
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:16 PM   #12
Taxman
 
Re: BRIAN BENDIS: THE BROAD VIEW OF SECRET INVASION

Quote:
Originally Posted by Marius665
Are we going to get an chance to do a Q&A with Mr. Bendis?
If you're interested at all there is a fairly large archive of audio Bendis Q&A here:

http://www.wordballoon.com/BENDIS.html
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:19 PM   #13
yonofui
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by MattBrady

Bendis: [laughs] I know there are a lot of people who think that Joe and I are pals, and I get to do whatever I want, and that is absolutely not the case. That’s why I work there. I don’t need working with “pals” in my life. I need someone who’s going to tell me that I suck when I suck - before it gets printed. So that’s good.


House of M, anyone? Do you remember that suck?

So, Joe Quesada told him that House of M suck, and then it was printed... LOL
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:22 PM   #14
GLG
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by artiepants
My rule on tie-ins after going a little nuts on CW (although i mostly enjoyed the tie-ins more then the main book, only thing i remember wishing i had skipped were the dreadful Fantastic Four issues.) is i only get what's already on my pull (which SI is pretty much touching on like 3/4s of my list) or something that has a creative team/premise/characters that would get me to try that book anyways. (i.e. Captain Britain and SI: Fantastic Four)

Smart man. That's always been my rule as well. I mean, when you take a step back from things if you've never followed a character and have no interest in them why would it matter what happens to them in the event? No need to pick up the Ms. Marvel tie in if you've never read nor cared about Ms. Marvel (just to pick on someone).
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:22 PM   #15
John [>H]
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by MattBrady
literally dozens of tie-in issues and spin-off miniseries.

This is far, far from a good thing for most readers.
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:23 PM   #16
spidey 85
 
sweet cant wait this is going to kill dc final crisis

Last edited by spidey 85 : 03-31-2008 at 03:52 PM.
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:25 PM   #17
Ian
 
While I've not really enjoyed how smart and unpredictable Bendis-penned books have the potential to be since his work on Daredevil, I think he's way beyond getting a tepid or apathetic response to his work.

He's superhero comic elite and people are going to check it out and weigh in...even with reservations. Which is where I find myself.

Like I said, I haven't felt like his Avengers work has been standout as far as Brian goes. Sorta mediocre for him. The Skrulls are due for a reprise and the ideas I'm hearing are compelling, but historically, the Skrulls have alway been their own worst enemies and speaking of Star Trek strike me as Ferengi-ish--with some comic relief in that they can't ever seem to use their formidable inherent abilities to really do anything but fall on their face time and again.

Let's not make the Skrulls such doofuses, huh? Unfortunately, I've seen some missteps with Skrulls roaming around without removing those they're attempting to pose as (see New Avengers #39 with a Skrull running around as DD while DD fights Mr. Fear in the streets in his own book--sloppy). Sowing seeds of confusion perhaps but also giving up their element of surprise prematurely I wonder. Also, the Skrulls don't seem to exhibit that they are well organized with some Skrulls attempting to infiltrate teams that we are told are already inhabited with Skrull spies (see New Avengers again where we are told that every team has a Skrull plant but they try and replace Echo unsuccessfully). This all basically amounts to editorial miscommunication and too many cooks in the kitchen that can happen all too often with event stories. This story seems unique in that in order for the Skrulls to seem like a viable threat instead of plot device this stuff either has to have a rationale or needs to be reigned in.

I realize these types of stories are meant to be very broad and you can't expect much from superhero readers to be all that critical--I mean, you can always fall back on the sentiment that it's just supposed to be mindless fun...but when you come off've a story like Civil War that seems to add up to selling more comics more than actual story rationale...when pro-regers are meeting up with anti-regers and all that's being given is the evil eye and a warning not to whatever it is they're doing and there are no real captures of anti-regers(read:criminal) by the pro-reg side then there is a fair bit of built-in cynicism for the next story attempting to be told.

That said, Bendis is capable of far better than what's been going on. And I realize now that this thing is outside of his control in the form of an event story he can't really be held responsible for the mismanagement of his idea but maybe that gives precedent for the next creative summit for somebody like Bendis to say, "Naw, I'd rather keep this in my own books so my idea doesn't get spread too thin and I take a hit." Y'know, avoid the temptation.

I hope Bendis can pull off a smart, logical and entertaining story with this. I know he's capable of it but I don't feel like he's really been at his best since DD. This's why I'm really pining for a solo series by him where he can focus in on a single character--build that character up and do what he does best.

And I agree about the promos--whoever is doing those...man, pure cheese. Is that like Greg Horn or something? blech.

Last edited by Ian : 03-31-2008 at 03:34 PM.
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:28 PM   #18
ElijahSnowFan
 
i've never said this about any storyline/creator/company in my life, but i'm going to say it now:

Bendis and Marvel are gonna get a pass from me about who is a Skrull and who isn't. they are.

because whichever decision was made, it's been planned. they talked about it, discussed it, argued about it. they weighed the pros and cons, and made the call.

that's all i've ever asked from a creator/company: to actually THINK about what they're doing before they DO it. to honestly weigh the merits.

i get pissed when a storyline appears to be rushed and when these things look shoddy in execution.

but i can honestly say that, while i may not like every reveal, i won't be bitching about it, because i know they planned it.

that's all i can ask.

and on that note: SWEET CHRISTMAS! LUKE CAGE IS A MOTHER-EFFIN' SKRULL!!
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:28 PM   #19
Marius665
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by yonofui
House of M, anyone? Do you remember that suck?

So, Joe Quesada told him that House of M suck, and then it was printed... LOL

I liked House of M. I just wish some thing came out of it. It seems like it happened and that's that. Unlike the Age of Apocalypse, some of those characters came back and are still around. I like that Hawkeye came back but others such as Synch could have also came back.

Bendis is like black liquorice, you either love him or you hate him.

I like all his work. But in my opinion, I feel that his down fall is his non-refernce of past experiences or other series involving the characters he writes.
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:29 PM   #20
House of J
 
Is this the thread for Nattering Nabobs of Negativism?
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:32 PM   #21
meatybucket
 
the promos look like Greg Horn's work. might as well be Greg Land's, as far as originality is concerned.
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:34 PM   #22
Punchy
 
I am much more excited about this than I realized.

Come on Thursday!
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:35 PM   #23
Edogawa1983
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by meatybucket
the promos look like Greg Horn's work. might as well be Greg Land's, as far as originality is concerned.

what's wrong with the Gregs...

we should pay more attention to Greg Pak from now on..
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:38 PM   #24
EdKaye
 
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz............ ...
 
Old 03-31-2008, 03:39 PM   #25
cosmictuna
 
Quote:
you can even buy the “Magneto was right!” t-shits



I don't care how cool they might be, I want nothing to do with Magneto t-shits. Sounds painful.
 
 
   

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:40 PM.


Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
© Imaginova Corp. All rights reserved.

imaginova LiveScience space.com aviation.com newsarama spacenews.com Adastra starrynight.com Orion Telescopes