Did "SI" Ruin Ms. Marvel or Iron Man yet?

[jackwtweeg]

I haven read Marvel od Dc for almost 2 months so. Did they ruin either character yet via Skrully?

[Kahn]

SI JUST started, so no. And I don't think Ms. Marvel can be ruined, anyway.

[sinosleep]

Honestly this is such bs. If noone important is a skrull people will cry because nothing of relevance happened. IF someone important is revealed to be a skrull people will cry because past stories will have been invalidated. Whatever..........

[Edogawa1983]

SI JUST started, so no. And I don't think Ms. Marvel can be ruined, anyway.

hey if giving birth to her lover didn't ruin her....

she's pretty much bulletproof in my eyes, unless she kills a baby or something

[jackwtweeg]

Honestly this is such bs. If noone important is a skrull people will cry because nothing of relevance happened. IF someone important is revealed to be a skrull people will cry because past stories will have been invalidated. Whatever..........

Everyone but Ms.Marvel or Iron Man can be a skrull

[Sighphi]

Actually Ms. Marvel #25 storyline does sort of ruin SI a bit or... the opposite.
But i think is basically going to happen with some of comic books that are going to get randomly thrown in because this is the new big event.

[miamiu]

With MS. Marvel you cant ruin something that is already broken.

[The Shadow]

With MS. Marvel you cant ruin something that is already broken.
You must not be reading the book.

[miamiu]

You must not be reading the book.

Very wrong I have and the book is one of the most inconsistent on the market. When I want to read more about machine man, sleep walker, and arana more than the main character of the book that shows the book has problems. Brian Reed makes everyone else interesting except the main character of the book.

[Max_Power]

Honestly this is such bs. If noone important is a skrull people will cry because nothing of relevance happened. IF someone important is revealed to be a skrull people will cry because past stories will have been invalidated. Whatever..........

Well ain't that the truth. The basic premise of Secret Invasion will either make it completely forgettable or and unending source of controversy.

Unless, you know, they change someone important and it works. It's Bendis so it can go either way. Personally, I think he'll go for someone big to be revealed as a Skrull. It's the only way Secret Invasion can really be considered relevant.

[sinosleep]

Well ain't that the truth. The basic premise of Secret Invasion will either make it completely forgettable or and unending source of controversy.

Unless, you know, they change someone important and it works. It's Bendis so it can go either way. Personally, I think he'll go for someone big to be revealed as a Skrull. It's the only way Secret Invasion can really be considered relevant.

For the me the bigger the better. I've never understood the whole invalidation thing any way, it's not as if a retcon magically shrivels your old comics into nothingness. They're still there in their long/short box, just the same as the day you bought em. They could make just about anyone a sleeper agent and it wouldn't bother me in the slightest. In fact I would think it was cool.

Finding out some characters in BSG were sleeper agents didn't make me care about them any less, it's the same thing here.

[TheJerkle]

Civil War gave Iron Man the edge he sorely needed to finally become an interesting character. If he were a Skrull it would take away from that wonderful character development

[ZeoVGM]

Very wrong I have and the book is one of the most inconsistent on the market. When I want to read more about machine man, sleep walker, and arana more than the main character of the book that shows the book has problems. Brian Reed makes everyone else interesting except the main character of the book.

Nah, it's a great fun read. Ms. Marvel is one of the best characters Marvel has going.

[Scelestus]

hey if giving birth to her lover didn't ruin her....

she's pretty much bulletproof in my eyes, unless she kills a baby or something

Truer words have never been written on Newsarama...

[artiepants]

to the OP: no.

[Dalarsco2]

Very wrong I have and the book is one of the most inconsistent on the market. When I want to read more about machine man, sleep walker, and arana more than the main character of the book that shows the book has problems. Brian Reed makes everyone else interesting except the main character of the book.
My thoughts exactly. I read her CW story and loved Arana, then I read her Initiative story because it was a lead-up to Omega Flight and I also really liked Arachne from the earlier issues.

[Zombie Uatu]

The only, literally the ONLY character I would be upset about if it turned out they were a Skrull is Iron Man, because it would make Civil War seem so much more sinister and not just a battle between ideals, which in my opinion would retroactively damage the story. But like one other poster said, yes the stories are still there, it's not like with BND where they're now telling a different story about another Spider-man with a different past to the one in my comic boxes.

[Sighphi]

For the me the bigger the better. I've never understood the whole invalidation thing any way, it's not as if a retcon magically shrivels your old comics into nothingness. They're still there in their long/short box, just the same as the day you bought em. They could make just about anyone a sleeper agent and it wouldn't bother me in the slightest. In fact I would think it was cool.

Finding out some characters in BSG were sleeper agents didn't make me care about them any less, it's the same thing here.


Is not a matter of how the character is perceived is a matter how it affects the story.
Tigh being little sense because the dude... sort of predates the Cylons doesnt he?
The dude is 60 something so how could the Cylons have a Skinjob before they grew sentient and wanted to leave?

Is basically the problem we have now with BlackBolt, we are trying to figure out when he was switched.